Tuesday April 29th 2003
Organic Food Industry "scaring the pants off
people" The Hudson Institute are trotting out another spokesman
on organics. Someone must have decided that the Avery clan are now
over-exposed (caught with their pants down too often?). Michael Fumento,
described as a "senior fellow" of the US ultra-conservative
organisation, is now been given a gallop. He tries to make the case that
" The organic industry has made a strategic error by demonising
conventionally grown foods which may be engineered to contain trace
amounts of synthetic pesticides." Fumento fumes further
"..organic farming is more expensive and
produces less attractive fruits and vegetables than conventional farming.
Despite an impressive growth rate, the category has achieved only a small
market share. So, to stay competitive, the organic industry devised a strategy of scaring the pants off people over the
alleged risks of even trace amounts of synthetic pesticides."
What can you say?
Have you anything to say?
I won't dignify this rot by giving you their web address - find it
yourself if you feel like a bit of intellectual slumming.
Food and environmental
toxins degrading childrens' health
On the other hand here is some solid if depressing information from a
respectable source.* It is in interesting counterpoint to the PR babble
above from the Hudson Institute.
To a large extent it also explains why the chemical industry can get away
with so much, and lazy (if not downright complicit!) government pesticide
control organisations escape their responsibilities. See highlighted para
below.
Bette Hilman* reviews the results of a recent meeting of US experts on
children's health. This is my quick summary:
* Bette Hileman is Senior Editor,
Chemical & Engineering News,
a publication of the American Chemical Society. See the full article, "Children's Health," published
in Chemical & Engineering News April 7, 2003, pps. 23-26 and www.rachel.org
for this and similar articles.
Here today; in Ireland, 20 years' time - maybe? California,
the Sunshine state, still outshines any other area on the planet with its
organic powerhouse of 40,000 acres of organic vegetables and 30,000 acres
of fruit. The state is also home to over 1,000 organic businesses.
And contrary to what the Averys/Fumento/Hudson Inst. say, there's no sign
of a drop in demand. According to Karen Klonsky,
agricultural economist at the University of California, Davis,
"natural food stores are going gangbusters" (that does mean
ballistic, doesn't it?).
Fischler's
pro-GM stance to run into Green wall Franz
Fischler, EU Ag Comm is now showing his true pro-GM colours. He is however
being closely monitored by the grouping, Green/European Free Alliance.
Walsh Euro MP Jill
Evans (Plaid Cymru - the Party of Wales), and also Green/EFA
spokesperson, has voiced serious concerns
about the motives of the European Commission in organising a seminar on
the co-existence of GM and non GM crops in the EU in Brussels recently. The
seminar was addressed by Fischler
who spoke of his hope that the discussion would help bring about 'the
co-existence of conventional and organic agriculture with genetically
modified crops in the EU'.
Ms Evans says; In Wales as in other parts of Europe we have seen overwhelming public
opposition to the wholesale introduction of GM crops. Today's event - and
Commissioner Fischler's remarks - clearly signal that the European
Commission is set on paving the way for genetic engineering in European
agriculture.
The Commission would do well to heed the advice of Parliament on this
issue which proposed Europe-wide legislation to require member states to
establish measures to prevent GM contamination.
What is urgently needed at this stage in the GMO debate is serious
discussion on how we establish measures to prevent GMOs contaminating
conventional and organic food, feed and seed. Conventional and organic
farmers producing for the vast majority of European consumers who reject
GM food should not be made responsible for the prevention of GMO
contamination. This is obviously something that should apply instead to
the producers and users of GMOs. The "polluter pays" principle
must be maintained otherwise the polluted will end up having to pay and
once again the consumer would be the loser".
See Fischlers speeches at http://europa.eu.int/comm/commissioners/fischler/index_en.htm.
Also look at the Commission's website for organic food and farming; http://europa.eu.int/comm/agriculture/qual/organic/index_en.htm
When is
organic not organic? When it's used to describe an "organic
experience", it seems, as opposed to organic ingredients.
Interesting, if slightly surreal debate raging in the beautiful-peoples'
state on the organic labelling of body-care products. One of the brands
getting the Californians' goat is Proctor and Gamble's, Clairol Herbal
Essences. Their use of "organic" describes the "shampooing
experience" only, they contend, not the contents. See Los Angeles
Times 22nd April.
Ja.
German is a wonderful language indeed I defer completely to a
German correspondent who has very correctly pulled me up on my use of
"Gaunereiirensupermarkte" (with an umlaut over the last
"a") to describe " Rip-off Irish Supermarkets".
Gaunereiirensupermärkte" (he obviously has an umlaut yoke on his
keyboard) he tells me " makes somehow (not great) sense, but is very
bad grammar." The expression that best fits what I want to say, my
informant insists, is "Irische Halsabschneider Supermärkte"
(got that umlaut by cutting and pasting) which literally translated, I am
assured, means "Irish cut-throat supermarkets". Next time I'll
just refer to them as bastards (Hunde?).
The same visitor points out that perhaps Aldi and Lidle are not beyond
putting their mitts (npi) in the cookie jar either; one example is a
can of beer in Lidl Ireland costing € 1.19 - same in Lidl Deutschland,
€ 0.29!* But to be fair, there is the little extra bit - the highest
alcohol tax in Europe! - that we pay Charlie McGreedy for the great
privilege of continuing to live here and occasionally affording a drink.
*That sounds just like the unit price
of my favourite beer, Lidl's Bergadler Premium Pils - brewed in accordance
with the mediaeval Deutschen Reinheitsgebot. I will not be put off
however, as the Bergadler is cheaper than almost anything else on the
Irish market and is as superior to the likes of Heineken/Bud/Carlsberg as
nectar is to cats' malarkey. In horror of the dreaded pub scenario,
"Everything's off except the Smithwicks", I have been known to
smuggle in a few Bergadlers. Once I was caught drinking it and asked to
leave - for not paying the rent!
Thursday
24th April 2003
So Shall we Reap when
published in September 2003, by Penguin, will be well worth buying. The
author, Colin Tudge, is visiting research fellow at the Centre for
Philosophy of Natural and Social Science at the London School of
Economics. The book deals with world agriculture and the role of science
within it. Tudge is a GM sceptic.
Done Deal Undone Remember the story of the sneak amendment to
a US bill going through the legislature? (See Archived Weekly News 11th
March, Deal cut a deal and Weapons of mass deception, 24th
Feb). Basically, Rep. Senator Nathan Deal slipped in a small clause into a
complex bill to allow non-organic feed to be used for organic livestock if
the price of organic feedstuffs went above a certain level.
When it was seen for what it was, many in the organic movement perceived it as a
kite-flying exercise to see whather the strict National Organic Programme
standards could be diluted.
For a
short while it was law in the US, but a hurricane of protest was aroused
and, within an extraordinarily short time, by 12th April, an amendment to the offending
clause was passed by both Houses.
Government and legislators were stunned at the pressure that was
brought to bear on them to repeal the Deal clause. Even the Secretary for
Agriculture, Ann Veneman, not noted normally for her support of organic
farming, was eventually in favour of repealing the Deal legislation.
The model standards of the National Organic Programme are still intact and
there is much justifiable glee among organic activists.
The clear, undiluted message sent out is: Mess with the bench-marking
standards of the NOP at your political peril!
Gaunereiirensupermarkte
(with an umlaut over the last "a") is the German for
"Rip-off Irish supermarkets". Would one of my German-speaking
visitors verify this?
Bia
Céad (? My Irish!) Around at a friend's house last night, I saw a
brilliant TG 4 programme - by accident. It was all about globalisation,
the agri-giants, bullying of developing countries by WTO, WB and IMF,
industrial agriculture and its catastrophic effects on world hunger
etc.
David Rosset, Anuraaha Mittel (beautiful woman!) of Food First and Dr
David Korten of Positive Futures Network were featured. Wonderful to hear
and see these people at long last.
Didn't get the beginning and don't have a schedule of programmes, so can't
tell you its name but it was on between 11 and 12 pm. And again, if my
Irish is up to scratch, I think they said it will be repeated next week.
Help!
Woe to the
rubbishers, for they shall be rubbished As I hadn't heard of any
response (have you?) forthcoming from anywhere else in the organic
community to the scurrilous "article" in the Indo last week, I
clicked out my own thoughts and zapped it off. I've been told it was
published but I haven't seen it yet. Anyone?
To the Editor of the Irish Independent.
Maeve Dineen's item on Tuesday's Farming supplement, "Organic
farming rubbished" is very old hat. Alex and Dennis Avery of the
right-wing American think-tank, the Hudson Institute, have been saying
these things about organic farming for years. That's what they are paid to
do by their corporate sponsors, which include many multinational
agri-businesses such as Monsanto.
They, and their anti-organic, pro-GM intensive farming propaganda have
been exposed and discredited several times.
The Avery's and their colleagues' favourite lines are "There is no
advantage, health or nutrition-wise in buying organic food." They
ask, " Where is the scientific evidence of the benefits of organic
farming?"
Well there are many substantial advantages, and there is also hard,
scientific evidence to support them. The most recent is research from
California that shows organic crops have over 50% more cancer-fighting
flavonoids than conventional food. This and other papers, such as
"Organic farming is as viable as conventional", "Organic
farming can feed the world" are detailed on my website
www.planorganic.com (open News&Comment page and click on
"Answering the organic attacks...").
The articles that I list are scientific, peer-reviewed research that
clearly demonstrate the benefits of organic food and farming.
None of what the Averys say or publish is peer-reviewed or backed with
accurate scientific information.
It is in a way flattering to the organic community that the Averys and
others like them are targeting organic farming with such negative
propaganda.
But it's easy to see why they would - world-wide sales of organic food are
now worth more than $25 billion and growing at over 25%. The organic
sector has now overtaken the market for GM crops in value terms and it's
debatable whether the controversy-ridden GM industry is going to grow any
further at all.
No wonder they are worried. Billions are at stake and in the absence of
facts they try to make their money talk through spin merchants like the
Averys. It must be very galling for the industry that they have to pay
extravagantly to have their angles projected, whereas the organic movement
largely relies on unfunded people like myself to make their case.
A look at the evidence I point to will undoubtedly show that it is the
anti-organic lobby that's "rubbished".
Sincerely etc.
And, whilst I was in letter-writing mode, I sent a dart winging its
way to the esteemed editor of the Daily Mail in response to the item
below. Somebody watch the Mail for me on this? I'll publish if they
publish!
Tuesday
22nd April 2003
Eat
organic for your health, not for flavour* (This is the title of a
letter to the editor of the Daily Mail**,10th April, in reply to an article The
Great Organic Con previously published in the paper. Anyone see the
original? It's not available online. Send me a copy of same, if you
will?
I was astonished to read the Great Organic Con (Mail), as the four women
interviewed appear to believe that eating organic is mainly about food
tasting better. Have they any idea what the cocktail of pesticides in all
our food - not just fruit and vegetables - can do to some peoples's
health?
Wheat, for example, concentrates pesticides in its grain more than any
other cereal. It does not matter how fresh your food is if it is
full of pesticides.
My 25-year -old daughter Kat was very ill for many years with ME (myalgic
encephalomyelitis) before I discovered that she was actually suffering
from organophosphate pesticide sensitivity.
I have since done an enormous amount of research on this subject.
Scientists are discovering that there are certain people who have this
genetic sensitivity and the discovery is also linked with other illnesses
such as some cancers, diseases of the nervous system such as Parkinson's,
Gulf War Syndrome and sheep dippers' flu.
My daughter now eats a totally organic diet and her health has improved
enormously. Having missed almost three years of school through chronic ill
health, she is back studying for seven GCSEs. She lost most of her
childhood, but her organic diet means she can now enjoy the good health
that most youngsters take for granted. Annie Hewitt, Tunbridge Wells,
Kent.
*
The August, 2002 issue of the UK magazine, Country Smallholding, had a fine article - Go organic-for the sake of your
health! - by smallholder and author Piers Warren. See, www.countrysmallholding.com
**I don't
read the Mail - it was used in packing some s/h computer gear I received
from a well-wisher.
Powerful
alternatives off the grid. By the
end of this summer I hope to have all alternative power. I am currently
(!) off the grid but I use a friend's supply to charge batteries and, I'm
ashamed to say, a back-up petrol generator - albeit a small one. However
by the end of the summer, at least in the power department, I'm going to
be as pure as driven snow.
I have recently been donated an array of second-hand, marine quality
Solarex panels. I need more bits, but I have jury-rigged a few panels to
charge batteries for the computer and the tractor - it's like magic -
power from the sun.
From the same generous source, I have also acquired a single cylinder,
diesel generator that, although looks a bit worse for wear, has a fabulous
engine. The dynamo/generator bit however is not producing the goods and,
having dismantled it, I can't really find anything wrong. I was expecting
to find brushes that I could just simply free up but this kiddo is a bit
more complicated. If anybody out there would like to help.....?
In the meantime, in anticipation of getting the generator resuscitated, I
have been looking up recipes for bio-diesel. I found what I wanted at; www.veggiepower.org.uk
(I love their description of the smell of the rapeseed oil/diesel mix,
"like popcorn or French fries").
Saturday
19th April 2003
Organic
farming rubbished. The Irish Independent carried a small but prominent
item, Organic farming rubbished, in last Tuesday's Farming
supplement. It wasn't journalism by any name, but simply a relay of a
weary old press release by the infamous right-wing American think-tank,
the Hudson Institute.Yes, you all know of it (if you've been reading my
site regularly) and the two Averys, Dinny and Al, whose pro-GM/intensive
agriculture and virulent anti-organic views are now notorious.
I am looking forward to seeing or hearing the outcry from the Irish
organic organisations at this cheap chirrup from the Indo. My budget
doesn't stretch to a subscription to a cuttings service, so, if you would
be my eyes on this, I would be grateful. jim@planorganic.com
Echo from
New Zealand The view in the following extract from an interview with
the ardent anti-GM activist Alannah Currie could equally apply to Ireland
or the UK.
"It makes no sense. New Zealand is an island nation
that sits in glorious isolation in the South Pacific. With vigilant border
controls, we could protect our unique GM-free status. We have the perfect
opportunity for the whole country to be GM-free and to capitalise on our
green image, not only environmentally but also economically. We could put
our scientific knowledge and funding towards organic, sustainable farming
and provide food for the world that is natural, varied and rich in the
spirit of our land."
And the way to achieve all this, says Ms Currie, in the face of the
vacuity and absence of vision of political and agricultural leaders, is
through consumer power;
"Our greatest strength, though, is as consumers. We all have purse
power and each and every one of us can exercise it as we choose."
Tuesday
15th April 2003
Sex in the Country I mentioned the Danish research on sperm counts of
organic farmers yesterday. Whilst I don't want to dwell too much on it -
for fear of being accused of something or other - it seems I'm not the
only one to remember that distant orgasmic research. An organic box scheme
operator in England, accepting the Soil Association award for Organic Business Person of
the Year recently, throws some further light on the subject. Guy Watson,
of the mightily successful Riverford Organic Farm*, said that not only did
the Danish findings confirm that healthy fertility follows an organic
diet, but twice as many of the samples from organic volunteers had to be
rejected because their donors had sex in the previous 48 hours (part of
the sampling controls).
I'm not certain, but I think this means that organic farmers are having
twice as much sex as conventionl farmers!
In any case, Guy Watson, ever marketing oriented, went on to speculate
that "The clear
conclusion must be that if you chomp your way through a veg
box each week, you are unlikely to need Viagra - but you better make sure
of your contraception."
*
Riverford Organic Farm and its franchisees distribute 5,500 vegetable
boxes throughout southern England.The majority of the produce is locally
grown. Contact mail@riverford.co.uk
and www.riverford.co.uk
Fear
the Danes Talking about organic box schemes and Danish sex
surveys, there is an even more successful box scheme operating in Denmark.
Referred to by its founder, Thomas Harttung, as the "Organic Full
Monty" the Aarstiderne Project supplies 30,000 boxes per week!
Turnover at almost € 20 million, represents 7% of total national organic
sales. The Full Monty soubriquet arises because, Thomas claims, all
aspects of the business are laid bare for inspection - by anyone, anytime.
That's coming clean!
The formidable Dane has an insight he wants to share with us all: “The
greatest impediment to an organic future are the supply chains that
operate intransparently (sic) and without a fair sharing of risks and
rewards".
Fatal Harvest ; The Tragedy of Industrial Agriculture, edited by Andrew
Kimbrell*, and published by the, intriguing sounding, Foundation for Deep
Ecology through Island Press.
I have had a review copy of this book for some time, and enjoyed
reading it immensely. Fatal Harvest takes an
unprecedented look at our industrial way of producing food and attempts to
detail a new ecological and humane vision for agriculture. Profusely
illustrated with over 250 colour photographs showing the current state of
our agricultural crisis, the book also features essays from more than 40
leading environmental thinkers, including Wendell Berry, Jerry Mander,
Helena Norberg-Hodge, Vandana Shiva, and Alice Waters.
I
will have the full review shortly on the Publications page but, in the
meantime, just take my word for it (or check Amazon or Google for reviews)
- and get it!
Hardback £ 62.50
Softback £37.50
Reader edition (Text without the illustrations) £14.50
UK postage £ 2.00
Irish and other EU £ 4.00
Support the publication(in anycase it may not be in the bookshops) by
ordering straight from the publishers at ;
The Eurospan Group
Island Press
3,Henrietta Street,
Covent Garden,
London, WC 2 E8LU
Email; colin.pierce@eurospan.co.uk
*Public interest attorney, activist and author Andrew
Kimbrell is considered to be one of the world's leading visionaries. Kimbrell is the Executive Director of the
International Center for Technology Assessment (CTA) and the Center for
Food Safety (CFS) in Washington, D.C.
GM crops: Do we need them? Are they safe? These
questions are to be the subject matter of a one-day conference in London
coming up next month. It will be based at Kings College on 10th May and
free tickets can be had by emailing ticket@i-sis.org.uk
Speakers will include, David Bellamy, Dr Mae-Wan Ho and Dr Arpad
Pusztai (he of the famous toxic GM potato row) and several others.
Go West, Young Man, to a seminar in lovely Westport hosted by
the Mayo Organic Group. The two-day event 10th - 11th May will
include, Identifying Local Plants, Spirit of the Garden, Herbs
into Ointments, and Sustainable Forestry. Judith Hoad will be one of the
speakers. Details from Joanna Moran, 098 42010 and Colm Cronin at cronin@anu.ie
Greepeace to torpedo Monsanto Aimed at
hitting where it hurts most - the corporate wallet - Grenpeace will
launch a report on the finacial status of the GM giant, Monsanto,
tomorrow. The report, commissioned from Innovest, is expected to warn
investors about weaknesses in Monsanto's strategies on GM foods and seeds.
See it when it hits the streets at www.greenpeace.org
Easter Eggs Before you splash out on the much-inflated, seasonal
offerings, look at David Storey's Organic Diary, 'Snap' decision gives
Easter its taste. And, whilst you're there, see the piece The Irish
Organic Sector: Busy going nowhere. www.organicmattersmag.com
Cornwall
goes GM-free Cornwall County Council recently voted 53 to 4 to have
the Duchy declared a no-go area for GM crops. They will also endeavour to
purchase only GM-free goods and services for the county. Other councils
have voted similarly.
Local papers were flooded with messages of congratulations.
Time for such motions to be put to Irish local governing bodies?
Dogs' Dinner You will be pleased to know that such things as pigs'
ears do not end up in Irish sausages. Instead, dried, they are sold as
dog's playthings.
A lot else however does end up in the limp, pink things, including limp,
pink things, and other "unmentionables", according to Dr Kenny of
the National Food Centre.
But the EU, ever our food watch-dog, is introducing a new directive on 1st
July to make sure that meat is meat and what's not meat, such as lips,
vulvas, udders tongues, hearts and stomach contents is defined as such and
labeled as such. Would this lead to such product descriptions as Dinny's
Silver Labia Sausages or puddingless Conaquilty Black Puddings?
If your stomach is still in the southern position after that, I offer my
delicious recipe for organic homemade sausages, without the pinkish bits
(I hope! Martin, you wouldn't, would you?) to anyone emailing me. jim@planorganic.com
Jewish
paper passes judgement on organics Wonderful where you find
interesting bits and pieces on the Web. The Jewish World Review this week
has an item Deciphering Organic Food Labels. The source may be
exotic but the content is pedestrian. But have a look anyway. http://jewishworldreview.com/0403/health_ex041403.asp
People Lost Anybody know Irish organic
farmers Oliver and Saskia Sullivan? Contact details for them would be
appreciated by a site visitor from Germany.
People Found I am continuously amazed at
where visitors to the site come from. The latest exotic is one from an ice
cream seller in the US Virgin Islands. And he was looking for the Prof
Mitchell paper - see April Fool Not below, 1st April.
Monday
14th April 2003
Food for
fat - Organic farmers to come under the microscope?
What causes obesity? A silly question, you might say. Sure we all know
the answers to that! But do we, really?
Eating and drinking too much, too little exercise, or a combination of
both, and, perhaps, also combined with a genetic disposition to be
over-weight, would be the usual suspects, you might say.
But you could be wrong.
According to a paper published by Dr Paula Baillie-Hamilton, Chemical
Toxins: A Hypothesis to Explain the Global Obesity Epidemic, the
current world-wide obesity epidemic cannot simply be explained by
overeating and inactivity. The problem may instead lie with the hugely
expanded production and usage of
synthetic chemicals in the last five decades. Environmental factors, like the
widespread use of growth promoters, she argues, are much more likely to be
the causative factors in obesity than genetics. Although a definite link
has not yet been established, the author says, the close coincidence of
the appearance of certain weight-promoting chemicals in our environment
and an obesity epidemic, cannot be ignored.
One of the areas of further research she suggests is "to compare
farmers who farm organically to farmers who farm conventionally." *
http://ramiro.ingentaselect.com/vl=25265194/cl=11/nw=1/rpsv/catchword/
mal/10755535/v8n2/s13/p185 Click on the
PDF option to get full article. If you experience difficulties, I can send
you a copy - jim@planorganic.com
* Would it be found that organic farmers are thinner
than their conventional colleagues? How would you factor in that organic
farmers probably work off more of their calories (definitely the
horticulural fellows anyway) than their sitting-on-machines counterparts.
Would the Danish research that showed that organic farmers had a higher
sperm count have anything to do with energy output? A hard one!
Friday
4th April 2003
Cheap Labour? Are you a
substantial organic horticulturalist? Are you plagued with labour problems
in those salad days when you have at least some tiny chance of making a
few bob: about to give up on most WWOOFers as being, although cheap,
unpredictable, lazy, or liable to run off with your partner or worse, your
car?
Well, this might be the answer to your prayers. Two hundred and fifty
willing students from Eastern European countries will be given special
visas to come to Ireland this year. And they are looking for host
employers.
The Seasonal Horticultural Workers Scheme, as it's called, run last year
as a pilot, is now going full throttle. A Bord Glas/Macra na Feirme
initiative, it is a decent attempt to tackle the problems of a shortage in
seasonal workers here and a lack of opportunity there. The visas will be
issued from 1st May to 31st October. Through their contacts with Eastern
European (Poland, Lithuania, Estonia and the Ukraine) agricultural
colleges, the Irish initiators of the scheme have already chosen the
students. So, visitors - PLEASE DO NOT APPLY (to me or anybody else) FOR
JOBS.
Unlike the WWOOFers' setup, however, you can't
dictate your own terms. These are not spailpeens - and you are expected to
be a good ambassaor for Ireland in your dealings withe these kids.
Only apply to offer employment if: a) you can give at least 12 weeks work
- preferably the full six months: b) pay the minimum wage
- at present, if you didn't
already know it, € 6.51 per hour, and c) arrange, suitable local
accomodation for the workers.
And, again, unlike the WWOOFers' scheme, it will be policed. Your
workplace and the proffered accomodation will be checked out, probably by
someone from Macra.
Apart from all that, I'm sure the scheme will find favour with many
hard-pressed horticulturalists. Last year no organic growers
applied.That may have been because they didn't hear of it. This time there
is no excuse. It will be interesting to see if anybody wants to be weaned
off WWOOFers.
Contact; declan.fennell@bordglas.ie
Bloody
Bloodstock Industry The Irish bloodstock industry got a bit of a
pasting on RTE Radio 1(Today with Pat Kenny) this morning. Andrew Tyler of
UK-based Animal Aid dished out gruesome data on racehorses,
"inbred", "raced to death"; "rape" (of mares that is), diseases, exhaustion, broken bones etc etc.
Only one third of horses bred for racing make it to the starting post
today, he maintained, compared to 80% long ago. The ones that don't make
the grade, Tyler says, "...end up as pet food, are fed to hunting
hounds or are exported or sold from owner to owner in a downward spiral of
neglect." Tyler further points out that 27 horses have died in the
Grand National since 1997. "Behind the friendly public image is a
ruthless industry motivated by vanity and commercial gain".
The plummy, as you'd expect, spokesman from the Irish Thoroughbred
Breeders' Association, Dr Des Leaden, had little to say apart from sounding plummy and
quoting a "peer reviewed" study from Trinity College (it would
be, wouldn't it) from 20 odd years ago and that "...the report was
very selective".
Tyler's original article Riding for a Fall and much more about this
subject can be seen on www.animalaid.org.uk
. Email them at, info@animalaid.org.uk
See also my articles in Archived News on "organic" bloodstock.
Solar Panel meets in Tipperary The Tipperary Institute, Thurles,
Co Tipperary is the venue today for the first general meeting of the Irish
Solar Energy Association. Michael Lyons of the Cork City Energy
Association is chairing the meeting. If it's interesting, I will report
the outcome next week. If I don't, and you are interested contact, michael_lyons@corkcity.ie
Lessening Children's Pesticide Exposure
More peer-reviewed research has just come to hand.
Researchers at the University of Washington compared
the organophosphate (OP) pesticide metabolite levels of Seattle pre-school
children. They found that children who consumed mostly (75%) organic
fruits, vegetables, and juices had significantly lower OP pesticide
exposure than those who consumed conventional foods. According to EPA
guidelines on pesticide levels those children consuming organic produce
were at "neglible risk".
Studies suggest that chronic low-level exposure to OP pesticides may
affect neurological functioning, neurodevelopment, and growth in children.Obviously if the children had followed a completely
organic diet the results would have been even more favourable.
Organic beats the bunch Good response to article
below on Prof Mitchell's paper.
Tuesday
1st April 2003
April Fool Not
If I were to tell you that out of the west
would come a star, a star of hope for organics, this being the day that it
is, you might think I'm having a little fun at your expense.|
Well, I have found such a star, and I assure you I'm not joking.
What's been hugely lacking in the field of organic research so far is hard
evidence, peer-reviewed, that organic produce has health or nutritional
advantages over conventional produce.
That evidence is now firmly in the arena.
Professor Alyson Mitchell of the University of California, Davis, has
shown organic crops can have up to 54% more flavonoids (the
very same anti-oxidant, cancer-fighting stuff that makes cranberries such
a strongly recommended health product ) than conventional produce.
The research is published in the Journal of Agricultural and Food
Chemistry, 2003, 51, 1237 - 1241.( I can, if you have difficulty finding
this, give you the full article, kindly and promptly supplied by Prof.
Mitchell. Email me at; Jim@planorganic.com
)
Prof. Alyson pondered that human health-giving flavonoids are a product of
plants reacting to pests in their environment. Remove the pests in
conventional crops with pesticides, she wondered, and would the plants
produce less flavonoids?
A commercial company wanted her to do comparative tests of their produce
for flavonoid levels. Among the samples sent to the laboratory were some
from their few organic suppliers. The company's main interest was the
effect of differing processing systems, air-drying, freeze, blast-drying,
on flavonoid levels in fruit and vegetables.
Prof. Alyson and their team also decided to investigate comparative
growing systems.
The results were a resounding Yes! for higher levels of flavonoids in
organic and sustainably-grown produce (and freeze-drying was shown to be
the most favourable processing method for preserving TPs).
The professor's own words best describe her motivations: "There is a
growing concern that the levels of some phenolics may be lower than
optional for human health in foods using conventional agricultural
practices. This concern arises because conventional agricultural practices
utilize levels of pesticides and fertilizers that can result in a
disruption of the natural production of phenolic matabolites in the
plant."
Prof. Mitchell sums up the breakthrough nature of this research:
"To our knowledge we show for the first time a correlation between
the applied agricultural systems (organic, sustainable and conventional)
of TPs (total phenolic) in marionberries, strawberries and corn..."
This research will be much discussed, I'm sure, and will undoubtedly, when
they sniff it out, attract the attention and opposition of the
agri-business, pro-GM giants. This is a result that will shake them to
their very foundations.
And it comes at a critical time in the overall debate between organic and
conventional systems as the value of the organic sector worldwide equals,
at $25 billion, that of GM produce.
The UC Davis team produced this research on shoe-string resources - total
cost approx. $35,000. Prof. Mitchell hopes to get more funds
together in the very near future to enable her team to continue to explore
the incidence of flavonoids in other fruit and vegetables grown under
different agricultural systems.
Let's hope she gets the money to do this extremely valuable work. Let us
also hope that her work will not be interfered with as has so often
happened with other researchers who produce results unfavourable to the
transnational conventional food industry.
Copywrite; Jim O'Connor, Planorganic.com
Budding
Farmers' Market I've just heard about a developing market in
Ennis, Co.Clare. It takes place on Saturdays, from 9 am to 2 pm.
It wouldn't yet be a full-blown farmers' market, but you can certainly buy
lots of great vegetables there. Normally, two certified organic growers
are present supplemented by a couple of non-certified organic producers.
Moves are on to upgrade the market and, in the near future, it is hoped to
have more producers and a wider range of produce.
"Where
the bee sucks...." Organic honey? How can you guarantee
that bees will only visit organic plants? Can somebody enlighten me as to
what the criteria are for producing organic honey?
I love my honey and am always on the prowl for the perfect nectar.
I tried a jar of Healey's Organic Honey recently. They are based in
Ballincollig , Co.Cork. It was not my taste however, too strong and
syrupy, and I won't be buying it again. Apparently it is imported - from
where, they don't say - and is certified by the Irish Organic Trust.
On the other hand, I bought, last weekend in Clare, non-certified Burren
Wildflower Honey which is sensational, delicate and intoxicatingly
perfumed. It is so good that I may add it to my gourmet porridge!
The label describes it as "Pure and natural, unheated and coarse
filtered honey
from Ben Johnson's apiaries in the Burren, Co.Clare".
Although it's a long, long way from Clare to here, I will be buzzing to
get more of this great honey sent down to me.
They've got a lot of things wrong in Co. Clare but this honey's not one of
them
Which would you buy?
Grand Slam Not At least not for Ireland. The Angles; they
came, they played, they slaughtered, they won. Even the ignorance of their
foul-mouthed captain, Johnson and his insult to the President cannot
detract from the thoroughness of their defeat of Ireland.
So much expectation...
If only we had got in a try before half-time, spirit might have carried
the day.
Feedback Reaction to the aricle last week, Irish Organic
Magazine - what a waste! is a bit like the proportion of the English
to the Irish score in the rugby match , 7 to 1; i.e. seven in favour of
what I reported - one against. One of the seven, once deeply involved with
the running of IOFGA, spent a long phonecall last night giving me his
strongly-held views.